When you make purchases through our links we may earn a small commission.
Photo Credit: instagram.com/thesmokingchair
In today’s political arena, welfare is often viewed with suspicion—mischaracterized as a crutch for the lazy or a giveaway for the undeserving. To counter this narrative, some policymakers have proposed “merit-based” welfare: a system where support must be “earned” through work requirements, drug testing, job training, or other conditional metrics. The premise sounds fair. But in practice, it creates a modern form of economic servitude—one that mirrors the logic of slavery more than most Americans would care to admit.
Let’s be clear: merit-based welfare is not a safety net. It is a leash.
Welfare conditioned on behavior is not aid. It’s a transaction. And like any transaction in a deeply unequal system, the terms are rigged. The idea that people must deserve food, shelter, or healthcare by satisfying bureaucratic hurdles presumes that these are rewards—not rights. But hunger is not cured by compliance. Eviction is not prevented by paperwork. And illness does not wait for job training to be completed.
When you only receive aid in exchange for labor, and that labor is mandated under threat of destitution, what you’re doing is not work. It’s forced servitude.
In many merit-based welfare programs—especially those involving “workfare”—recipients are compelled to perform menial jobs in order to receive assistance. These jobs are often unpaid, menial, or unconnected to long-term employment opportunities. The state effectively extracts labor from its poorest citizens in exchange for the barest essentials of life.
If a corporation required someone to clean its offices or maintain its grounds in exchange for food, we’d call it exploitation. If a government requires the same in exchange for avoiding starvation, we call it “responsibility.” Both are coercive. One just hides behind the language of policy.
Supporters of merit-based welfare claim it’s about encouraging independence and reducing reliance on government. But if you are one missed shift or one failed drug test away from homelessness, that’s not freedom. That’s economic coercion with the smiley face of reform.
In the antebellum South, enslaved people were told their value depended on their productivity. Today, welfare recipients are told their worth is measured by job applications submitted or hours clocked at state-approved placements. In both cases, people are denied autonomy and treated as tools—valuable only when useful.
A truly compassionate society asks: What do people need to thrive? Merit-based welfare asks: How can we extract value from the poor before giving them anything at all? The first question leads to dignity, innovation, and growth. The second leads to stagnation, resentment, and wasted human potential.
How many artists, inventors, caregivers, or students have been denied support because they couldn’t meet a narrow definition of “merit”? How many were forced into exhausting, unproductive labor just to prove they were worthy of survival?
Slavery was not just an institution of forced labor—it was a system that denied people the right to self-determination. Merit-based welfare does the same, dressed up in modern clothing.
The alternative is not “lazy giveaways.” The alternative is unconditional, universal support—ensuring that no one starves or sleeps on the street because they failed to jump through bureaucratic hoops. Universal Basic Income, flat tax refunds, or social safety nets without strings are not handouts. They are investments in freedom.
Because freedom doesn’t mean the opportunity to earn your way out of misery. It means the right to pursue your potential without fear of losing everything.
You’ll get more articles like this – and our favorite promotional offers delivered straight to your inbox.
By submitting this form you agree to our terms and conditions. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Newark Mayor Ras Baraka Files Lawsuit Against U.S. Attorney Alina Habba Over May Arrest
Newark Mayor Ras Baraka has taken legal action against U.S. Attorney Alina Habba, claiming his arrest in May was politically motivated and defamatory. The lawsuit, filed in federal court, challenges the handling of his detainment outside a Newark immigration facility and seeks accountability from top federal officials.
Why Pathological Liars Believe They Always Tell The Truth
Why do some people lie so often—and still feel honest? This article dives into the psychology, brain chemistry, and emotional survival mechanisms behind pathological lying.
The Science Behind The Slow Drinker
Drinking five drinks a day sounds excessive—until you understand the science behind slow drinking. By consuming alcohol at a controlled pace, the body metabolizes it efficiently, preventing extreme intoxication and reducing health risks. Learn how slow drinking impacts your BAC and why context matters when it comes to alcohol consumption.
2025 NFL Draft: Ranking the Fastest-Releasing Quarterbacks
Which 2025 NFL Draft quarterbacks get the ball out the fastest? This in-depth analysis ranks the top prospects by average time to throw, highlighting strengths, weaknesses, and how quick decision-making impacts their draft stock.
If You Can’t Afford $9 to Drive Around Manhattan, You Can’t Afford to Drive Around Manhattan
Congestion pricing has finally untangled Manhattan’s gridlock, saving time for commuters and clearing the air. If $9 a day feels unaffordable, it might be time to rethink whether city driving is practical.
BREAKING: IRS UNCOVERS TRILLIONS IN UNPAID TAXES FROM WEALTHY ELITES
A shocking IRS report exposes massive tax evasion among the ultra-wealthy, with trillions in unpaid taxes over the past decade. Lawmakers demand urgent action.
