Why Pathological Liars Believe They Always Tell The Truth

When you make purchases through our links we may earn a small commission.

Why Pathological Liars Believe They Always Tell The Truth
Why do some people lie so often—and still feel honest? This article dives into the psychology, brain chemistry, and emotional survival mechanisms behind pathological lying.
Facebook
LinkedIn
Print
Reddit
Threads
Share
Article Contents

Pathological liars are some of the most perplexing people we encounter. They lie habitually, sometimes about matters so trivial that there’s seemingly nothing to gain. What’s even more bewildering is that many of them truly seem to believe their own fabrications. How is it possible to lie so consistently yet feel so honest? To understand this paradox, we have to explore how self-deception, psychological defenses, and brain chemistry intertwine to create a reality where the liar becomes the believer.

The Line Between Deception and Delusion

Pathological lying, also known as pseudologia fantastica, is different from the occasional white lie or the strategic omission of facts. It’s compulsive and often serves no clear purpose. Over time, these lies don’t just manipulate others—they reshape the liar’s own perception of reality.

Many pathological liars don’t just lie to others; they lie to themselves. And through repeated storytelling, they often begin to internalize the falsehoods. When someone tells a lie enough times, especially with emotional conviction, their brain can start to record that memory similarly to a true event. This phenomenon is known as “source misattribution”—the brain remembers the content, but forgets it originated from imagination rather than reality.

Self-Deception as Survival

Pathological liars often have underlying psychological issues—trauma, low self-esteem, personality disorders such as narcissistic or borderline personality disorder, or a deep fear of rejection or insignificance. The lies they tell aren’t always meant to harm others; sometimes, they’re constructed defenses against a painful truth.

If admitting failure, vulnerability, or inadequacy feels too threatening, the mind can invent and reinforce alternative narratives. These stories may begin as conscious fabrications but eventually become emotionally necessary fictions. In other words, the liar believes the lie because the truth is too painful to accept.

Brain Chemistry and Reinforcement

There’s also a neurological component at play. Some studies have shown that the brains of chronic liars are wired differently. A 2005 study published in the British Journal of Psychiatry found that people who lie compulsively have more white matter in their prefrontal cortex, which may increase their ability to manipulate information and construct elaborate stories.

Over time, lying can become a reinforced habit. Each successful lie—one that avoids punishment or earns admiration—rewards the brain with a hit of dopamine. Like any other addictive behavior, this neurochemical reinforcement makes it harder to stop. And with each retelling, the line between fact and fiction blurs even further.

Confirmation Bias and Selective Memory

Pathological liars often exhibit confirmation bias, seeking out only the evidence that supports their beliefs—or their preferred version of reality. When confronted with contradictory facts, they may reinterpret, ignore, or outright reject them. This isn’t always intentional; it’s a form of cognitive dissonance reduction—a mental tactic to maintain internal consistency.

Their memory also becomes selective. They genuinely forget details that don’t fit the narrative they’ve constructed and overemphasize those that do. In their mind, they’re not lying—they’re simply sharing “their truth.”

A Mask That Becomes a Face

Perhaps the most haunting reason pathological liars believe their own lies is that, after a while, they have to. Lying can begin as a tool for control, comfort, or attention—but once it’s entrenched in a person’s identity, it’s no longer a mask. It’s a face.

The person behind it may have long since lost touch with who they really are or what the truth even was. The lie becomes their reality—not because they set out to deceive the world, but because the world became too painful to face without the lie.

Final Thoughts

Pathological liars are often seen as manipulative, dangerous, or even evil. But behind the deception often lies deep psychological pain, broken trust, and a desperate need for validation or control. Their belief in their lies isn’t always a malicious act—it can be a symptom of deeper wounds and distorted self-perception.

Understanding this doesn’t excuse the behavior, but it offers a framework for compassion and, potentially, intervention. Because in the end, the most dangerous lie a person can tell is the one they come to believe themselves.

Text It

Hey, I read something really interesting I wanted to share—it’s about why pathological liars actually believe their own lies.
It’s long, but seriously eye-opening. 👇


Why Pathological Liars Believe They Always Tell the Truth

Ever known someone who lies all the time… even about stuff that doesn’t matter? And when you call them out, they swear they’re telling the truth? 🤯

Turns out, many pathological liars truly believe the lies they tell. It’s not just manipulation—it’s something much deeper.


It starts with how the brain stores memories.
When someone tells a lie enough times, especially with emotion, their brain can start to record it like a real memory. It’s called source misattribution—you remember what you said but forget that it was made up. Eventually, it feels like the truth.


But why lie in the first place?
For many of these people, lying is emotional survival. They might struggle with low self-esteem, trauma, or personality disorders like narcissism or borderline personality disorder.

Telling the truth might feel too painful—so they create a more bearable version of reality. At first, it’s a defense mechanism. But the more they repeat it, the more they need it.


Their brain literally reinforces the behavior.
A 2005 study found that compulsive liars have more white matter in their brains, especially in the prefrontal cortex. That gives them a greater ability to make up stories and keep track of lies.

Plus, every time a lie “works”—gets praise, avoids punishment—they get a little dopamine boost. Like a habit or even an addiction, it becomes automatic.


Then comes the confirmation bias.
They subconsciously seek out anything that supports their version of the truth… and ignore or reject everything that doesn’t. Their memory becomes selective.

So when they say something false, they’re not necessarily trying to deceive—they honestly believe they’re right. Because in their mind, they are.


Eventually, the lie becomes their identity.
What starts as a mask becomes a face. After telling the same story so many times, they lose touch with who they were before it began. The false version of reality becomes all they know. Not out of malice, but because the truth is too hard to face.


Bottom line?
Pathological liars often aren’t trying to hurt you. They’re trying to protect themselves—from shame, fear, or feeling unworthy.

That doesn’t make the behavior okay, but it does help explain it. It’s not always evil. Sometimes, it’s brokenness.

Because in the end…
The most dangerous lie someone can tell—is the one they come to believe themselves.

Subscribe

You’ll get more articles like this – and our favorite promotional offers delivered straight to your inbox.

By submitting this form you agree to our terms and conditions. You can unsubscribe at any time.

A cozy, dimly lit setting with a glass of whiskey on ice, a lemon twist, and a clock in the background, symbolizing slow and mindful alcohol consumption.

The Science Behind The Slow Drinker

Drinking five drinks a day sounds excessive—until you understand the science behind slow drinking. By consuming alcohol at a controlled pace, the body metabolizes it efficiently, preventing extreme intoxication and reducing health risks. Learn how slow drinking impacts your BAC and why context matters when it comes to alcohol consumption.

Read More »
A stylized digital illustration of a Black Hawk helicopter flying over Washington, D.C., with a stormy sky and social media icons fading into the clouds, symbolizing misinformation.

The F-Files: Unmasking the Misidentification of a Fallen Pilot

When tragedy strikes, misinformation spreads fast. A viral wave of false claims misidentified a fallen Black Hawk pilot, linking her to a transgender woman and a former White House aide. This F-Files investigation breaks down the truth, the logical fallacies used, and the dangers of unchecked social media narratives.

Read More »
A symbolic digital illustration featuring a split-screen design. On one side, a silhouette of a politician speaks into a microphone, while on the other, a social media feed displays exaggerated headlines and out-of-context quotes. The background includes abstract digital elements such as floating text, news articles, and a distorted magnifying glass, symbolizing misinformation and political manipulation.

The D Files: Haley’s Role Model

Did Nikki Haley really call Hillary Clinton her “role model”? A political ad says yes—but the truth tells a different story. This fact-check uncovers the selective editing, logical fallacies, and the role of social media in distorting political narratives.

Read More »