Unveiling the Appeal to Common Practice Fallacy: A Critical Examination

ChatGPT

Connect With Us

When you make purchases through our links we may earn a small commission.

Photo Credit: Brian Lawson
Put It On Your Wall: CanvasOnDemand.com

Uncover the nuances of the Appeal to Common Practice fallacy in this insightful article. Explore examples, understand implications, and learn how to identify and avoid this reasoning pitfall. Enhance your critical thinking skills and contribute to more rational discussions by recognizing the limitations of relying on common practices as a basis for argumentation.

Help us spread the word about policies that are good for all Americans for only $1.99 a month – every dollar helps.
🇺🇸
Don’t forget to ‘Like’ our social issues Facebook page, Partisan For The People, where you can comment on – and share – all our latest posts.

Understanding the Appeal to Common Practice

The Appeal to Common Practice fallacy relies on the idea that if something is widely accepted or commonly practiced, it must be correct or justified. However, the frequency with which a belief or action occurs does not necessarily make it valid or reasonable. Just because “everyone does it” does not provide any substantive evidence or support for the legitimacy of a claim.

Content Continues Below

Examples of the Appeal to Common Practice

“Everyone in our office takes office supplies home. It’s just what people do.”
“If you’re famous grabbing women is fine; they’ve been doing it for a million years.”

In the first example, the fact that everyone takes office supplies home does not make it morally or ethically acceptable. Similarly, the second example assumes that because they’ve been doing it for a million years, it must be acceptable practice.

Implications of the Appeal to Common Practice

Engaging in the Appeal to Common Practice can lead to flawed reasoning and weak arguments. Accepting a belief or behavior solely based on its prevalence overlooks the need for substantive evidence or rational justification. This fallacy can hinder critical thinking and impede the pursuit of truth.

Identifying the Appeal to Common Practice

To recognize the Appeal to Common Practice, pay attention to arguments that rely on the frequency of a practice rather than its merits. Look for statements that imply something is right or acceptable solely because it is commonly done, without providing any valid reasons or evidence.

Avoiding the Appeal to Common Practice

Scrutinize assumptions: Question whether the argument is based on the popularity of a practice rather than its inherent merit.
Seek evidence: Demand substantive evidence or reasons to support a claim, rather than accepting it simply because it aligns with common behavior.
Consider alternative viewpoints: Evaluate the argument critically and explore alternative perspectives that may challenge the notion of common practice as a valid justification.

The Last Word

The Appeal to Common Practice fallacy serves as a reminder to approach arguments with discernment. Just because a belief or action is widespread does not make it automatically valid or justified. By being aware of this fallacy and applying critical thinking skills, individuals can contribute to more rational and well-supported discussions.

READ: What is Universal Basic Income? A Small Government Policy for Fueling Capitalist-Driven Solutions